Retirement village residents can lose up to 45% of their in-going payment in a so named 'deferred fee' without ever gaining ownership of their unit but still pay the 'ownership' costs like maintenance costs, renovation costs, selling costs, administration costs. #springst #vicpol pic.twitter.com/sJwZeVKJwD
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) January 8, 2020
Saturday, 11 January 2020
Loss of Capital Savings
Friday, 6 September 2019
Reality of Diverging Retirement Village Capital Journeys
Reality of diverging capital journeys made by #retirementvillage operator and residents. NSW Gov't wants operators to repay 0% interest loans from residents 6 not 18 months after they leave. Industry crying ruination. @Kevinandersonmp @GladysB @mckay_jodi @NSW_FairTrading #nswpol pic.twitter.com/TztfhVQuiy
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) August 2, 2019
Tuesday, 30 July 2019
Financial Reality of Retirement Village Living
The financial reality for many retirees from living in a retirement village. In-going $800,000 capital turns to almost dust after just 10 years (industry average) of occupancy. #retirementvillage #auspol @neighbour_s @sdanck @adele_ferguson @MichaelWestBiz @acccgovau pic.twitter.com/x8Mw3u9l5s
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) July 26, 2019
Tuesday, 16 July 2019
Drain of Retiree Capital Wealth
How much does this excessive drain of capital away from retirement village residents ultimately cost the taxpayer and the Aged Care budget. When will the government 'really' look at what is happening. @richardmcolbeck @JulieCollinsMP @JoshFrydenberg @AlboMP #agedcareRC #auspol pic.twitter.com/PjDdEJ2ltU
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) July 15, 2019
Transfer of Capital Wealth from Retirees.
Transfer of capital wealth from retirees to retirement village operator. All licensed and approved of by state government. One village, 150 units. Encouraged by federal government who complains about aged care funding costs. @JoshFrydenberg @agedcare @acccgovau @NSW_FairTrading pic.twitter.com/DOvBoMyROr
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) July 12, 2019
Best Retirement Village Fix
Best Retirement Village Fix-Ban the Deferred Management Fee model-Legislate to simply buy or rent-Retiree retains capital making them better placed to fund their own Aged Care not rely on taxpayers. #auspol @richardmcolbeck @JulieCollinsMP @HelenHaines1 #agedcarerc @neighbour_s pic.twitter.com/VOhyzDZAli
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) July 8, 2019
Wednesday, 3 July 2019
Financial Destiny of Retirement Village Resident
Interesting to compare the financial destiny of a Victorian retiree on entering a #retirementvillage as opposed to that of a profit driven operator. And all this comes with the assistance of State Government legislation. #vicpol @abc730 @acccgovau @MarleneKairouz @michaelobrienmp pic.twitter.com/vPpWoDLTXC
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) July 1, 2019
Financial Data From Retirement Village Examination
This is staggering, no need for a 1000 words of explanation. Just look at the numbers and remember this is just one (1) yes just one retirement village. @DanielAndrewsMP @michaelobrienmp #vicpol @sdanck @abc730 @acccgovau #auspol pic.twitter.com/eriNArQF5N
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 29, 2019
Sunday, 30 June 2019
Impact on Aged Care Funding
The transfer of intergenerational wealth. The numbers in the table give it some perspective. The impact on @agedcare funding is scary. This is just ONE village not all of them. #agedcare #agedcarerc @abc730 @acccgovau #auspol @ScottMorrisonMP @JoshFrydenberg @AlboMP @neighbour_s pic.twitter.com/E9U8XRsSTl
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 25, 2019
Sunday, 23 June 2019
The Transfer of Intergenerational Wealth.
"Families need to be aware that what we are talking about here is the transfer of intergenerational wealth, not to families, but into the pockets of large multi-nationals. Shame about elderly people not having enough money for aged care."
![]() |
Saturday, 22 June 2019
Retirement Village v Residential Tenancy v Family Home
Retirement Village versus Residential Tenancy versus Retain the Family Home. The answer, as always in the $ numbers. @MarleneKairouz @michaelobrienmp #vicpol @sdanck @abc730 @acccgovau See the chart below. pic.twitter.com/oUMX5MwsIr
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 21, 2019
Transfer of Intergeneration Wealth not to Families
Retirement Villages="The transfer of intergenerational wealth, not to families, but into the pockets of large multinationals"-Tom Gait. Everything you need to know about #retirementvillages is in that statement. @MarleneKairouz @michaelobrienmp #vicpol @sdanck @abc730 @acccgovau pic.twitter.com/F0Jmwj46KX
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 19, 2019
Negative Impact on Capital Wealth of Retirees
Legislators would not tolerate this #retirementvillage mess for their own mum & dad. Yet fail to reform laws that create a devastating negative financial impact on the capital wealth of residents leading to entering a 'poverty trap' hidden from them at the outset. @abc730 #vicpol pic.twitter.com/yKNN8feWeU
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 18, 2019
Long Wait for Loan Repayment
It will be people like this who have to wait up to 12 months to get their money back on leaving a retirement village. Commercial operators escape the need for working capital retention with the legislative protection of Sate Governments. @Kevinandersonmp @sdanck @NSW_FairTrading pic.twitter.com/ReA7Secvzu
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 12, 2019
Tuesday, 11 June 2019
No Moral or Financial Justification
What moral or financial justification for elderly residents of #retirementvillages to wait months to get their own $ amount back on leaving. They do not own only lease. Gov't 'Free Kick' to commercial operators. @DanielAndrewsMP @MarleneKairouz @michaelobrienmp #vicpol @sdanck pic.twitter.com/aVanHtFzl0
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 6, 2019
Deferred Management Fee Destroys Retiree Life Savings
As the entry cost to lease a unit in a #retirementvillage moves closer to the buy cost of a commensurate unit within the general community, the greater the Deferred Management Fee model destroys retiree life savings. #auspol @acccgovau @MarleneKairouz @Kevinandersonmp @sdanck pic.twitter.com/nL4CcONF1g
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) June 6, 2019
Wednesday, 5 June 2019
Retirement Village Equals Destruction Of Retiree Capital
Retirement Village = destruction of retiree capital, reduces retiree capacity to fund own #agedcare costs, taxpayer has to pay more. Capital destruction from simply a lease/licence to occupy. #auspol @KenWyattMP @JoshFrydenberg @acccgovau @abc730 pic.twitter.com/eE0QQIeIGL
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) May 20, 2019
Tuesday, 21 May 2019
Destruction of Retiree Capital from Retirement Villages
Destruction of retiree capital from entering a #retirementvillage. Creates inability for retiree to change direction and reduces capacity to fund own #agedcare costs on departure. Taxpayer has to chip in to support. #auspol @KenWyattMP @JoshFrydenberg @acccgovau @abc730 pic.twitter.com/MUwAlWLerN
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) May 19, 2019
Friday, 10 May 2019
How Grandma and Grandpa Become Corporate Financiers
If you are a legislator and you don't understand this story, then you shouldn't be making laws about retirement villages. https://t.co/l9ksrahTZ9 A must read for all legislators.
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) May 6, 2019
@Matt_KeanMP @MarleneKairouz @acccgovau @consumervic @MatthewGuyMP @abc730 #vicpol @DanielAndrewsMP pic.twitter.com/xb4OYT87aI
Saturday, 4 May 2019
Danger for Retirement Village Residents
DANGER DANGER for #retirementvillage residents from falling property prices. Although only a lessee access to capital gains also means responsibility for any capital losses. @DanielAndrewsMP @MarleneKairouz @michaelobrienmp #vicpol @abc730 @acccgovau @sdanck @GladysB #NSWpol @smh pic.twitter.com/6PnF0GexpW
— Les Scobie (@retvilldotnet) May 2, 2019
Function of Government

Popular Posts
-
Victorian legislators failed retirees with an inability to fully understand the Retirement Village industry, the Deferred Management Fee bus...
-
What is wrong with Victorian loan/lease retirement villages? Property Ownership is never granted. You paid for it but you don't get to...
-
The following is an article published in the September newsletter of the consumer and advocate body Residents of Retirement Villages Victori...
Labels
- 100 million
- 4 Corners
- ACCC
- Aged
- Aged Care
- Aged Care Royal Commission
- Aged Pension
- Ageing at Home
- Aging
- Aging in Place
- alzheimers
- Ambassador
- auction
- Australia
- Aveo
- Average Resident Comparison Figure
- Big Battery
- Bush Fire
- CALC
- capital
- capital gains
- capital loss
- carers
- Climate Change
- Code of Conduct
- Commissioner
- Commonwealth Government
- Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Contracts
- Corona Virus
- Cost
- COVID-19
- Deeming
- Deferred Management Fee
- Detailed Calculator
- DSCV
- Ecocide
- Economy
- Election
- Emergency
- Emergency Plan
- emotional
- Evacuation
- Extinction
- Fair Trading Dpt.
- Family Home
- Fees
- financial
- fossil fuel subsidy
- Franking Credits
- Frog in hot water
- frydenberg
- Global Warming
- Government Inquiry
- Goverrnment
- Growth and Innovation
- HAAG
- harm
- Home Care
- Homebuilder Scheme
- Housing
- Imputation Credits
- in-going amount
- Industry
- Irrigation
- Kiva
- Labor Government
- Lease
- Legislation
- Lendlease
- life savings
- Loan
- LSIC
- Lying
- maintenance charge
- Margin Lending
- Merry Christmas
- Misleading
- Morrison
- New South Wales
- Newstart
- Ombudsman
- Omnicide
- Overcharging
- Pensioner
- Poverty
- Profit Driven
- property
- Property Developers
- Queensland
- Reform.
- Reforms
- Refurbishment
- Rent Assistance
- Residential Tenancy
- Residents of Retirement Villages Victoria
- Retiree
- retirees
- Retirement
- Retirement Living
- Retirement Living Ombudsman
- Retirement Village
- Retirement Village Law
- Royal Commission
- RRVV
- seniors
- Social Distancing
- Social Housing
- Solar Power
- State Government
- State Laws
- Stockland
- Super Concessions
- Superannuation
- Superannuation Concessions
- Taxi
- Taxpayer
- Travel Auction
- Travel Insurance
- VCAT
- Victoria
- Victorian Government
- Victorian Labor Government
- Wind Power
