Showing posts with label Consumer Affairs Victoria. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consumer Affairs Victoria. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Has Consumer Affairs got it wrong?

Has Consumer Affairs Victoria got it wrong?

Les Scobie a long-time advocate for reforms to the Victorian Retirement Village industry writes -

Consumer Affairs Victoria has published a guide titled Retirement village adjusted maintenance charge calculation. (CAV Guide)

It makes the following claim in reference to the adjusted maintenance charge -

"This figure is the previous year’s adjusted maintenance charge increased in line with the consumer price index (CPI). It is not necessarily based on the amount that was actually charged in the previous year."

Note the words 'not necessarily' meaning not always. A claim that there are occasions where it is based on the amount that was actually charged in the previous year.

BUT WHAT DOES THE LAW SAY -

Section 38aa of the Victorian Retirement Villages Act 1986. (Austlii.edu.au)

(1)     The adjusted maintenance charge for a relevant financial year for an existing retirement village or a new retirement village that has been in operation for at least one relevant financial year must be determined in accordance with subsection (2).

(2)     For the purposes of subsection (1), the adjusted maintenance charge must be determined for each relevant financial year for the retirement village in accordance with the formula— A x (B/C) where— A is—

(i)     subject to subparagraph (ii), the adjusted maintenance charge for the previous relevant financial year for the village; or

(ii)     in the case of a new retirement village that has been in operation for only one relevant financial year, the maintenance charge for that relevant financial year for the village;

s38AA2(ii) mandates 'BASED ON THE AMOUNT THAT WAS ACTUALLY CHARGED IN THE PREVIOUS YEAR' occurs only once in the life of a village, that being the second full year when the adjusted maintenance charge is calculated for the very first time.

Section 38AA creates independently of the maintenance charge, a standalone cpi compounding value to which the proposed maintenance charge is compared (benchmarked) for the purposes of Section 38(2) of the legislation. 

The calculation and application of the Section 38AA calculated adjusted maintenance charge is the primary protection afforded village residents against rampant or unauthorised fee increases above cpi each year.

Australian consumer law prohibits a business from making misleading statements - 

Chapter   2 -- General protections

Part   2 - 1 -- Misleading or deceptive conduct

18   Misleading or deceptive conduct

(1)  A person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.

Les Scobie contends that the statement by Consumer Affairs Victoria - 'It is not necessarily based on the amount that was actually charged in the previous year' will mislead residents. Leading to residents being exploited financially through paying a maintenance charge at a value higher than the legislation requires of them.


Thursday, 17 September 2026

Retirement villages. The $100 million bureaucratic jumble

Potential gap between what retirement village operators charge residents and the actual cost could hit retirees for up to $138 million, retiree rights advocate writes.

Residents at retirement villages operating under Victoria’s Retirement Villages Act 1986 (RV Act) are being charged more for village maintenance and management — the service charge — than what the law requires.

This occurs where operators deny residents the statutory right to choose to pay a service charge from two separate values — the service charge as proposed by the operator, or an independently calculated benchmark value.

According to the legislation, residents are not required to pay a monthly service charge higher than this independently calculated, CPI-compounding benchmark value — unless the residents agree to do so (except for the first year. The service charge is based on the operator’s estimated operating costs for maintenance and management of the village for the new village year; the benchmark value compounds each year using the % change in the Australian Bureau of Statistics Table 9 Melbourne CPI index.

See the full story at the link below - 

Retirement villages. The $100 million bureaucratic jumble

Tuesday, 28 July 2026

Victorian Retirement Village Residents Exposed to Financial Exploitation

The Victorian State Labor Government began reviewing the Retirement Villages Act in 2017, after some 9 years they failed to fix one of the most serious of problems.

How the statement by Consumer Affairs Victoria leads to Victorian retirement village residents being exposed to financial exploitation by paying a maintenance charge greater than they have a statutory obligation to pay.

The statement by Consumer Affairs Victoria is from page 13 of their booklet A Guide to Living in a Retirement Village. It is contended that the statement misleads the entire Victorian industry when it comes to the methodology used to calculate the $ value of the maintenance charge. Whilst the statement may have been purposely simplistic given the nature of the publication, it has been adopted and practised by village operators statewide as law.

The misleading statement -

“The retirement village can only increase your maintenance charge in line with the annual Consumer Price Index (CPI) adjustment.

A bigger increase is only allowed if it is approved by a resolution of the residents’ committee or a resolution of a majority of the residents.”

The statement guarantees the payment of a ‘maintenance charge’ at a $ value greater than village residents have an obligation to pay under the act. It deprives residents of the statutory protections afforded them under Sections 38.1, 38AA, 38.2, and 38.4 of the Retirement Villages Act.

The page 13 CAV statement incorrectly prescribes that the primary question to be asked in each and every year of village operation is – is the increase in the maintenance charge to be greater than a cpi increase. Residents are afforded protection under Section 38.2 which mandates the primary question each year is - is the $ value of the proposed maintenance charge to be greater than the Section 38AA cpi index % increased adjusted maintenance charge.

The ‘adjusted maintenance charge’ is not the previous maintenance charge adjusted for cpi. The confusingly named adjusted maintenance charge is a Section 38AA cpi calculated, standalone, $ value. A value to which the proposed maintenance charge is compared (benchmarked) for the purposes of affording residents protection under Section 38.2 each year.

The page 13 statement incorrectly prescribes that a Section 38.4 vote of residents is only required in those village years where the increase in the maintenance charge is greater than a cpi increase. Section 38.4 mandates a vote of residents in each and every village year where the $ value of the maintenance charge is to be greater than the Section 38AA cpi calculated adjusted maintenance charge.

Table A and then Table B below establish that for a village of 90 units, with a maintenance charge in the first full year of $624.00 per month, residents are misled into paying $357,062.62 more in their maintenance charge than obligated to pay under the RV Act. Using the Consumer Affairs methodology in Table A - 

1. The operator sought and was granted authority by unsuspecting residents in years 2 and 6 under the invalid CAV methodology of - the increase in the maintenance charge was greater than a cpi increase.

2.The operator contended that resident authority was not required in years 3,4,5, 7 & 8 under the invalid CAV methodology of – the increase in the maintenance charge was not greater than a cpi increase.

                                                                              Table A

Under the methodology espoused by Consumer Affairs Victoria, the operator failed to calculate a $ value for the statutory ‘adjusted maintenance charge’ despite having an annual obligation to do so under Section 38AA of the RV Act.

Table B below uses the provisions of Section 38.1, Section 38AA, Section 38.2 and Section 38.4 of the Victorian Retirement Villages Act to calculate the maintenance charge. The outcome over years 3.4.5.7.& 8 of village operation is a payment by residents of $357,062.62 in their maintenance charge above their statutory obligation to pay.

                                                                             Table B

 
Table B above calculates the $ value of the maintenance charge using the statutory provisions of Section 38.1, Section 38AA, Section 38.2 and Section 38.4
of the Victorian Retirement Villages Act.

The fee overpayment stems from -

1. The village operator in calculating the maintenance charge used the invalid methodology espoused by CAV in Page 13 of their booklet A Guide to Living in a Retirement Village. The actions of the village operator breached the provisions of Section 38.1, Section 38AA, Section 38.2 and Section 38.4 of the RV Act.

2. The operator failed to calculate in each and every village year (excl 1st) a $ value for the poorly named, stand alone, Section 38AA cpi calculated adjusted maintenance charge. (One is shown in Table B to illustrate the magnitude of the financial exploitation problem)

38.1 - "adjusted maintenance charge" means the adjusted maintenance charge determined and indexed in accordance with section 38AA;

38AA(2) - For the purposes of subsection (1), the adjusted maintenance charge must be determined for each relevant financial year for the retirement village in accordance with the formula—

3. The operator failed to compare (benchmark) the value of the proposed maintenance charge to a $ value for the Section 38AA cpi calculated adjusted maintenance charge. This action denied residents the protection afforded them each year under Section 38.2 of the RV Act.

38(2) Despite anything to the contrary in a residence contract, a management contract or the bylaws a resident is not required to pay a maintenance charge to the extent to which it is greater than the adjusted maintenance charge.

4. The failure of the operator to compare (benchmark) the value of the proposed maintenance charge to a $ value for the Section 38AA cpi calculated adjusted maintenance charge also denied residents the protection afforded them under Section 38.4 of the RV Act. That in each and every year where the operator proposes a maintenance charge at a $ value greater than the Section 38AA cpi calculated adjusted maintenance charge, village residents are granted the statutory right to choose which of the two values they will pay.

38(4) Subsection (2) does not apply if the payment of a maintenance charge that is greater than the adjusted maintenance charge has been approved by resolution of a majority of the residents at a meeting of tthe residents or is approved by resolution of the residents committee.

Table B establishes that residents were misled into paying some $357,000 more in their maintenance charge than they were obligated to pay under the provisions of Section 38.1, 38AA, 38.2 and 38.4 of the Victorian Retirement Villages Act.

This example is for an industry average size village of 90 units and paying an industry average size $624 per month toward village operating costs. There are some 450 villages in Victoria, housing some 36,000 Victorian retirees, operating under the provisions of the Retirement Villages Act. A frightening $160 million dollars in unauthorised charges over the period.


Monday, 31 March 2025

Retirement Villages What is Wrong

The critical importance of retirement village resident submissions to Victorian state government inquiries is that they are actually living the experience not simply 'working in the field'. They know what is wrong because they have experienced it, suffered from it.

Victorian retirement village residents find that there is almost zero protection when something goes wrong, or the system to obtain that protection is so cumbersome, so demanding on them, that surrender is ultimately the chosen option. And village operators know that and use it to their own financial advantage.

All this from a Victorian Labor government that fails to enforce the law as it is currently written, let alone to improve it to protect the very people it was originally written to protect.

"The law was clearly on the side of the village residents. It was a lack of access to affordable, quick, decisive enforcement of the law that failed them most". - Retvilldotnet

Retirement villages, the process of for-profit operators seeking financial reward from this commercial activity under the guise of the provision of benevolent housing for older Victorians. Sadly and particularly in Victoria the commercial risks to operators are dampened by statute whilst at the same time the commercial rewards are enhanced by statute. 

For Victorian retirees who make that fateful decision to enter a retirement village it is the complete opposite. The payment of the capital value of the village unit, not for ownership simply occupancy. The payment of all the costs of property ownership with none of the rewards.

"Families need to be aware that what we are talking about here is the transfer of intergenerational wealth, not to families but into the pockets of corporations. Shame about the elderly not having enough money for aged care."

So what is wrong with Victorian Retirement villages, the answer is -

  1. Bureaucrats who don't really know or fully understand the product they are producing legislation for.
  2. Legislators who don't really know or fully understand the product they are enacting legislation for.
  3. State Governments who are far too easily seduced by slick marketing from the industry.
  4. A failure of all of the three parties above to listen to the one group of people who really do know and fully understand the product, the village residents and their families. 
Village residents understand because they suffer financially from the legislative inequities produced by Bureaucrats, Legislators, State Governments.


retirement village poverty trap






Tuesday, 21 April 2020

Know Your Rights

Friday, 20 March 2020

Consumers Challenges Holiday Auction Value

Friday, 28 February 2020

Consumer Referral to ACCC

Wednesday, 25 December 2019

Fairness A Key Element For Consumer Protection

Monday, 23 September 2019

Government Publication Has Capacity to Mislead

Victorian retirement village resident raises with Minister for Consumer Affairs Marlene Kairouz the matter of a publication of the department 'Guide to buying and living in a retirement village' that has material which is false, misleading or has the capacity to mislead.


"I wish to raise the issue of statements that have the 'capacity to mislead' consumers made in the booklet downloadable from the Consumer Affairs web site. The booklet being - Guide to choosing and living in a retirement village.


There are three major points of concern all with the capacity to mislead consumers are -


Page 15 - Deferred Management Fee "how not-for-profit villages improve their services or subsidise maintenance charges". There is nothing in the Retirement Villages Act 1986 that requires an operator to do this, in fact they can and do contract away from it by including a statement in the contract of occupation that Deferred Management Fees are 'for their own use absolutely'. The statement in the booklet is simply not true in every case and clearly has the 'capacity to mislead' consumers.


Page 17 - Capital Gains - The statement that 'most contracts share any capital gain between the resident and the village owner' has the 'capacity to mislead' consumers as the use of the word 'most' is simply not true. Industry data has shown that only 41% of Australian village contracts share capital gain. It is difficult to imagine Victoria is completely isolated from this industry ratio.


Page 21 - Auditing of Financial Statements - The statement "the financial statement must be audited. unless residents have agreed by special resolution" - Operators can and have applied for exemption to this mandate under - Section 6 of the Act – (1) Any religious or charitable organization may apply to the Director to have the organization declared an exempt organization for the purposes of all or any of the provisions of this Act. The statement on page 21 of the booklet has the 'capacity to mislead' consumers as the statement is simply not true in every case.


All three issues above relate to material that is false, misleads or has the capacity to mislead retirees when it comes to selecting an individual retirement village or the sector itself.


I was deeply disappointed and saddened by an initial reply on the matter- “The Guide itself contains a clear disclaimer that information which it contains about the law may be expressed in general statements so as to avoid the use of technical legal language.”


I do not seek more 'technical legal language', simply accuracy which would remove the capacity to mislead. Rather than fix the issue the department seems to simply hide behind the disclaimer, to me this is simply not good enough from a government department.


The ACCC is very clear as to corporate responsibility when it comes to misleading statements and I see an even greater responsibility for governments and government departments.


“It is illegal for a business to make statements that are incorrect or likely to create a false impression. It does not matter whether a false or misleading statement was intentional or not”


It is the role of government to enable a commercial environment for the retirement village industry, but it is surely not the role of government to contribute to mis-information which can be at the direct financial benefit of operators whilst at the direct financial and emotional cost of Victorian retirees.


In the interest of Victorian retirees the document should be amended to remove the misleading or capacity to mislead components.

• The statement in the booklet, Page 15 - Deferred Management Fee "how not-for-profit villages improve their services or subsidise maintenance charges" is simply not true in every case. Without the need for any technical legal language the statement should be amended to read for example "how some not-for-profit villages may improve their services or subsidise maintenance charges" .

• Page 17 - Capital Gains - The statement that 'most contracts share any capital gain between the resident and the village owner' is simply not true. Industry data has shown that only 41% of Australian village contracts share capital gain. Without the need for any technical legal language the statement should be amended to read for example ' some contracts may share any capital gain between the resident and the village owner' .

• Page 21 - Auditing of Financial Statements - The statement "the financial statement must be audited. unless residents have agreed by special resolution" is simply not true in every case. - Operators can and have applied for exemption to this mandate under Section 6 of the Act. Without the need for any technical legal language the statement should be amended to read for example "the financial statement must be audited unless residents have agreed by special resolution, some organisations however can be granted an exemption."

Those Who Have A Responsibility To Care Don't

Misleading Retirement Village Information

Sunday, 30 June 2019

Publication With Capacity To Mislead

Urgent Need For Review of Retirement Village Act

Tuesday, 25 June 2019

Minister Questioned Over Retirement Village Inaction


Tania Maxwell MP Member for Northern Victoria questions Consumer Affairs Minister Marlene Kairouz over the lack of action on Retirement Village reform.


"My adjournment matter is for the Minister for Consumer Affairs.

It is about the ongoing delay in the Government’s response to the report of the Legal and Social Issues Committee’s Inquiry into the retirement housing sector that was tabled in March 2017.
Of all the matters canvassed by the committee in that report, the two to which I would like to direct the most immediate attention are covered by Recommendations 2 and 15.  Respectively, they called on the Government to:
  • review the Retirement Villages Act 1986, following sector-wide concerns especially around dispute resolution and transparency of disclosures; and
  • introduce a new alternative for low cost, timely and binding resolution of disputes, through a new body or by extending the powers of an existing ombudsman.
I wholeheartedly support both those recommendations, because they speak to changes which are still clearly and urgently needed.

Even as recently as last month, the Minister for Consumer Affairs was still saying the Government is committed to holding the review and further considering dispute resolution processes in retirement villages.

So, set against all of that background, the action I seek from the Minister is the provision of a definitive statement on the public record about when the review of the Retirement Villages Act 1986 will specifically begin.  As well as when a new body or extension of the powers of an existing ombudsman will be enacted to protect consumers.  In turn, I also ask that the Minister specify who is conducting the review, what its terms of reference are, and when it will report."

Read the full transcript here:- http://taniamaxwell.com.au/adjournment-review-of-the-retirement-villages-act-1986/




retvill.net logo

Saturday, 22 June 2019

Retirement Village Minister Questioned in Parliament

Decade Without Meaningful Retirement Village Reforms

Thursday, 20 June 2019

Cost Of Leaving A Retirement Village

The ABC 7.30 Report has drawn attention to continued problems within the Retirement Village Industry.

Emphasis was drawn to the much maligned Deferred Management Fee and the lack of meaningful consumer protection available to residents when something goes wrong in their village.

Take the link below to watch the full story.

https://www.abc.net.au/7.30/the-cost-of-getting-out-of-a-retirement-village/11226126

Tuesday, 21 May 2019

Capacity to Mislead Retirees

Sunday, 16 December 2018

Retirement Villages Greatest Untouched Consumer Issue

Function of Government

The role of government is to create an environment for commerce to function whilst at the same time protecting retirees and particularly vulnerable retirees from both financial and emotional harm emanating from that function.

The Victorian Retirement Villages Act 1986 provides the environment for commerce to function but fails to fully protect retirees from financial and emotional harm as a result of it.

The Victorian legislative definition of a retirement village in demanding the payment of an 'in-going' amount without the transfer of property ownership is a major contributor to that financial and emotional harm suffered by retirees.


retvill.net

Popular Posts

Labels